Skip to main content
2026

Nate’s Notes 287: Mean Time To Ethical Failure | David Miller, On-Call Ethicist and Former Princeton Professor

By November 18, 2026No Comments

David Miller

Senior Fellow at the Center of Theological Inquiry and president of the Avodah Institute and Author

I loved David’s story about the IBM technician who replaced a $250,000 component even though it wasn’t broken. IBM knows that eventually every component will fail, so rather than waiting for something to break, they replaced critical parts before they reached their expected failure point.

We are all like those machines in that we all have a mean time to failure. Given enough pressure, stress, or exhaustion, even good people will make bad decisions. And rather than assuming we’ll always do the right thing, we should strive to prevent ethical failures before they happen.

I also loved the story about David’s friend who carried a resignation letter in his pocket for 40 years, as a reminder that he would never compromise his values just to keep his job. Using it three times, he was fired twice, and once promoted.

Finally, I appreciated David’s reminder that ethical decision-making requires looking through three different lenses: rules, consequences, and virtues. What moral principles, rules, or duties should guide our behavior?  What good or harm may result? And what would a virtuous person do? Each perspective helps us see things the others might miss.

In summary, ethics isn’t just about making the right decision in the moment. It’s about building the habits, reminders, and courage that make the right decision more likely when under pressure.

It’s a simple idea. Please take it seriously.

David Miller Bio:

David Miller spent 18 years as a professor at Princeton University, where he directed the Faith & Work Initiative. Before entering academia, he spent 16 years as a senior executive in international business and finance, including eight years in London. Today, he serves as a senior fellow at the Center of Theological Inquiry and president of the Avodah Institute. His latest book is The 5 Questions for Ethical Decisions: How to Succeed Without Selling Your Soul.